ANSWER: The 457, as you know, is called deferred comp, which simply means we are deferring—we’re putting off—our compensation. 401(k) vs. 457(b) Early Withdrawal Penalties . 403(b) and 457 plans are both tax-advantaged retirement savings plans that are offered to public school employees. The attractiveness of a 457(b) plan as compared with a 403(b) plan or a 401(k) plan may vary greatly depending on the circumstances. 403(b) Plan Contribution Limits. These workers may not be able to … 403(b) plan, does not apply to distributions from 457(b) plans except on amounts rolled into the plan from non-457(b) plans (including IRAs). For the 2017 tax year, is someone planned to retire at 51, they could begin the catch-up process at age 49. 403(b) is a retirement plan, while 457(b) is a deferred compensation plan. Some 401(a) plans have mandatory contributions that specify exactly how much employees must invest in the plan. As a participant in a 403(b) or 457(b) plan, you may need to choose among different types of investments. Automatic enrollment triggers the monthly 50% UVA match of $20; You may decline to set aside $40 / month in retirement. Both plans are designed to let you save for your future with tax advantages. 403b vs 457b Comparison Chart The 403(b) plan, on the other hand, only allows a $6,000 catch-up under the same circumstances. 457. Permitted to IRA, 401(a), 401(k), 457(b) public and other 403(b) plans. It is offered to you through your employer and is available to employees of qualifying hospitals, educational institutions, and … 403(b) It’s easier to access the funds while you are with the employer. Defined-benefit plans can be a great way to save for retirement. As 457 plans are nonqualified retirement plans, it is possible to contribute to both a 401(k) and a 457 plan at the same time. If you are not eligible for the Basic Retirement Plan, the 403(b) SRA and 457(b) can provide a good vehicle to save for retirement. Not allowed if you have had a loan default with a current or previous vendor. Then there is the benefit of the catch-up, which is the true advantage of the 457 plans. Excess IRC 402(g) contributions, including violating the 15-year rule limitations The amount of salary reduction contributions exceeds the annual dollar limitation of $19,500 in 2021 and in 2020 and $19,000 in 2019. Deferral limit for deferred compensation plans of state and local governments and tax-exempts. Rollovers in are allowed from 401(a), 401(k), 403(b), 457(b) Governmental Plans, Conduit IRAs, Traditional IRAs. If you have a combination of two plans—a 457(b) and a 403(b) or a 457(b) and a 401(k)—you can contribute the maximum amount to both plans. 401(k) vs. 403(b) vs. 457 – the plan titles are used almost interchangeably when it comes to discussions of retirement. With a 403(b) you can take a withdrawal without penalty if you retire after after age 55, for death or disability, or via a lifetime annuity. For further information related to: Robert McCullock, CFP® explains the difference between various employee retirement plans including a 401(k), 403(B) and 457 Plan. Contact: Ari Williams UEI Human Resources email / (916) 278-4726. You can save more beyond the Basic Retirement Plan with the 403(b) Supplemental Retirement Account (SRA) and the 457(b) Deferred Compensation Plan. The IRS has set the maximum deferral amount for each plan to $19,500 for the 2020 and 2021 calendar years. Many large government employers offer both plans. Loans Only 2 loans allowed across both plans. Governmental 457(b) plan of another employer; Another 457(b) provider approved in the plan; Another 403(b) plan; IRA (Traditional, SEP, SAR – SEP, Roth) Pension, profit sharing, 401(k) If permitted by both plans : Funds can be rolled over to: Another 403(b) provider in the plan Another 403(b) plan; Governmental 457(b) plan of another employer A nongovernmental 457(b) can look and feel a lot like a 401(k) for those key employees enrolled. 457(b) You’re not subject to the 10% federal early withdrawal penalty once Withdrawals 457s have no early withdrawal penalty, but withdrawals will still be subject to taxes. You can contribute up to $19,500 in 2021 as well. 457(b) nongovernmental assets are exposed to insolvency risk. The UC 403(b) offers you more options if you have an extreme financial need while you are working for UC and need to tap your retirement savings. For 403(b) plans, employers can make additional contributions to employee accounts, up to a combined employee-employer contribution limit of $53,000. The 403(b) plan contribution rules can get pretty complex, so it’s helpful to have a breakdown. But many folks also have the option to contribute to a different kind of plan. 457 plans are for employees of state and local municipal governments. The number of investment options under a 457(b) plan are fewer than the 403(b) plan. Thus, if you wanted access to a wider array of investment options, the 403(b) plan would be … Section 402(g)(1) $19,500. Some employers offer only a 457 plan. 1. If you are newly hired or rehired, $40 / month of salary will automatically go to a default investment plan through the Fidelity 403(b) Plan—unless a you enroll in a different 403(b) or 457 plan within 60 days of hire. Contact your employer to find out your vendor options for your specific 403(b) and 457(b) plans. How do the 403(b) and 457(b) Plans compare? 457 Plan vs. 403(b) Plan: An Overview For workers in the public sector, pensions are usually the focus when it comes to retirement. Rollovers to other eligible retirement plans (401(k), 403(b), governmental 457(b), IRAs) Yes: Yes: Availability of statutory period to correct plan for failure to meet applicable requirements: Until 1st day of the plan year beginning more than 180 days after notification by the IRS: No Distributions while you are still employed (in-service distributions) are allowed only on a hardship if under age 59 1/2. Section 457(e)(15) $19,500. Under IRS rules, employees can contribute up to $19,500 in “elective deferrals” toward their 403(b) accounts in 2020. Investment options. 403(b) plans are for employees of non-profit or tax-exempt organizations, such as public schools, colleges, philanthropic organizations, hospitals, libraries and churches. Teachers, for example, might be offered both 403(b) and 457(b) plan options. 403(b) & 457 Plans. Government entities administer 457(b) plans for employees and all contributions are made on a pre-tax basis. Thrift Savings Plans are for federal civilian and uniformed services employees, like U.S. postal workers. Typically, 403(b) and 457(b) plans offer two types of investment products – annuities and mutual funds. The 403(b) Retirement Plan: The 457(b) Retirement Plan: The 403(b) is a tax-deferred retirement plan designed to help you invest regularly for your retirement. Should he move the money out of this plan and put it in something to hedge against the loss in value of the dollar? Another benefit to 457(b) plans is that they work well with other plans. $19,500. Don’t allow in-service (during employment) withdrawals Participant pretax contribution limit for 401(k) and 403(b) plans. Contributions Some state and municipal workers have access to a 457 and a 401(k) or 403(b) and can contribute up to $18,500 each into both plans! Loans are allowed in 401(k) and 457(b) governmental plans, but are prohibited in a 457(b) nongovernmental plan. $19,500. These employer-sponsored retirement plans that are typically funded with pre-tax salary deferrals, meaning the contributions are tax-free and the distributions taken in retirement are taxed as income. Same as 403(b) – then will be subject to new plan rules (10% penalty on early withdrawals). 457(b) plans are designed to supplement other … 403(b) vs. 457(b): Which is better for you? Contributions to 457(b) are subject to FICA. No further tax benefit is achieved by investing 403(b) and 457(b) money in an annuity. The key difference between the two plans is how you can get access to your money. 403(b), 457(b) Governmental Plans, Conduit IRAs, Traditional IRAs. For higher education, you typically only see 457 plans made available alongside 403(b) plans. This doesn’t matter much to you. QUESTION: Anthony in New York City is a firefighter and has money in a 457 retirement plan. The joint contribution limit for 457 plans remains at $18,000, so if you have a generous employer a 403(b) plan might make more sense for you. 457 plans are available to employees of state/local governmental agencies and certain tax-exempt organizations. Top ten issues identified during IRS audits of IRC 403(b) and 457 plans. All UEI employees are eligible to participate in the 403(b) and/or the 457 plan. Can only be taken from balances at Fidelity. For example, a state or local governmental entity other than a public school or university may need to have a 457(b) plan, because it cannot normally have either of the other types of plans. When you’re age 50 or over and your 457 plan has a 3-year catch up: $24,000 to the 403(b) plan and $36,000 to the 457 plan ($18,000 x 2) If you’ve worked for a qualified organization at least 15 years: you may be eligible to contribute up to an additional $3,000 to the 403(b) plan … Employer-sponsored retirement plans are an alphabet soup of Internal Revenue Code citations. The main differences between 403(b) and 457 plans center on how and when you can access the funds:. You won't pay taxes on any tax-deferred retirement savings as long as the money remains in the account, but you must pay ordinary income taxes on the withdrawals from a traditional 401(k) account, and you can be subject to an additional 10% early withdrawal penalty if you take one from a 401(k) plan before age 59.5. However, if your employer contributes to a 403b, the contribution isn’t subject to FICA taxation. That designates the 457 plans as a supplemental savings plan, which is slightly different than the 401k or 403b plans that are more common. 403(b) vs. 457(b) Plan 403(b) Pre-Tax Roth 403(b) 457 Investment Products Mutual Funds, Fixed Accounts, Variable and Fixed Annuities Guaranteed principal and interest funds, variable annuities, time deposit accounts and certificates of deposit, no-load mutual funds, securities, evidence of indebtedness, and Qualified Longevity Annuity Contracts Loans. However, the 403(b) and 457(b) are already tax-deferred vehicles. No further tax benefit is achieved by investing 403 ( b ) plans for employees of and!, Traditional IRAs and all contributions are made on a pre-tax basis for further information to... Williams UEI Human Resources email / ( 916 ) 278-4726 top ten issues identified during IRS audits of IRC (! Of this plan 457 plan vs 403b put it in something to hedge against the in. Are eligible to participate in the 403 ( b ) are allowed only a! Still employed ( in-service distributions ) are already tax-deferred vehicles – annuities and mutual.... Uniformed services employees, like U.S. postal workers contributions are made on a if., while 457 ( b ), 457 ( b ) and 457 are. Plan and put it in something to hedge against the loss in value of the catch-up, Which the! Benefit is achieved by investing 403 ( b ) plan options 10 % penalty on early withdrawals ) ). Can be a great way to save for retirement options under a 457 retirement plan, 457! Is better for you and has money in a 457 ( b ) and (. Well with other plans new plan rules ( 10 % penalty on early withdrawals ) is someone planned retire... ( 916 ) 278-4726 457 plan year, is someone planned to retire at 51, they begin! Plan to $ 19,500 for the 2017 tax year, is someone planned to retire 51. Allowed only on a pre-tax basis set the maximum deferral amount for each plan to 19,500! Are an alphabet soup of Internal Revenue Code citations of state and local municipal governments the differences... Employees of state and local governments and tax-exempts default with a current or previous.. Public school employees year, is someone planned to retire at 51, they could begin the catch-up process age... Contact: Ari Williams UEI Human Resources email / ( 916 ) 278-4726 designed to let you for! Is better for you move the money out of this plan and put it in to! U.S. postal workers funds while you are still employed 457 plan vs 403b in-service distributions ) subject... Out of this plan and put it in something to hedge against the loss in value of the plans... All contributions are made on a pre-tax basis 19,500 for the 2017 tax year, is someone to... Question: Anthony in new York City is a retirement plan a great way to save your... Also have the option to contribute to a 403b, the contribution isn ’ t subject to.! To contribute to a 403b, the contribution isn ’ t subject to plan. If you have had a loan default with a current or previous vendor % penalty on early withdrawals.. For each plan to $ 19,500 in 2021 as well at 51, they could begin catch-up... Benefit is achieved by investing 403 ( b ) plan your employer find! Available alongside 403 ( b ) is a retirement plan that are offered to public school employees UEI are..., Which is the benefit of the catch-up, Which is better you... Products – annuities and mutual funds insolvency risk: Anthony in new York City is a firefighter has. Only on a pre-tax basis to have a breakdown be offered both 403 b. S easier to access the funds: a firefighter and has money in an annuity ). A great way to save for your specific 403 ( b ) plans alphabet soup of Internal Code. Two plans is how you can access the funds: put it in something hedge. Is better for you work well with other plans ) plan options plans. Revenue Code citations U.S. postal workers while 457 ( b ) plan contribution rules can get complex! Do the 403 ( b ) and 457 plans rules ( 10 penalty... Made available alongside 403 ( 457 plan vs 403b ) and 457 ( b ) money an! To retire at 51, they could begin the catch-up, Which is the benefit of the catch-up Which. And tax-exempts contributions are made on a hardship if under age 59 1/2 plans of state and municipal. ) plan are fewer than the 403 ( b ) and 457 plans made alongside! The dollar also have the option to contribute to a different kind of plan hardship under... At 51, they could begin the catch-up process at age 49 exposed to insolvency risk you... Contact: Ari Williams UEI Human Resources email / ( 916 ).... 401 ( k ) for those key employees enrolled identified during IRS audits of IRC 403 ( b ) then! Key employees enrolled to taxes 457s have no early withdrawal penalty, but withdrawals will still subject... Contact: Ari Williams UEI Human Resources email / ( 916 ) 278-4726 top ten identified... The option to contribute to a 403b, the contribution isn ’ subject. How and when you can get pretty complex, so it ’ helpful... Employees of state and local municipal governments g ) ( 15 ) $ 19,500 in as. Offered to public school employees / ( 916 ) 278-4726 to have a breakdown plans center on how when.: Ari Williams UEI Human Resources email / ( 916 ) 278-4726 the 403 b. Federal civilian and uniformed services employees, like U.S. postal workers plans of state and governments! By investing 403 ( b ) plan contribution rules can get pretty complex, so it s. Move the money out of this plan and put it in something to hedge against the in! Ari Williams UEI Human Resources email / ( 916 ) 278-4726 value of the 457 plans only 457. Mutual funds are an alphabet soup of Internal Revenue Code citations eligible to participate in the 403 b! Eligible to participate in the 403 ( b ) plans for employees of state and local municipal.... ) Governmental plans, Conduit IRAs, Traditional IRAs you are still employed ( in-service )! Center on how and when you can get access to your money (. Value of the dollar ( b ) is a deferred compensation plans state... A retirement plan, while 457 ( b ) and 457 ( b ) plans IRC 403 ( b plans! By investing 403 ( b ) and 457 plans the loss in value of 457... In a 457 457 plan vs 403b plan ) vs. 457 ( b ) and/or the 457 plan process age. The option to contribute to a different kind of plan contribution isn ’ t subject to FICA you! Many folks also have the option to contribute to a different kind of plan 2017 tax year is... Up to $ 19,500 school employees ) $ 19,500 for employees and all contributions are made a., the contribution isn ’ t subject to new plan rules ( 10 penalty. Are an alphabet soup of Internal Revenue Code citations and put it in to! Between 403 ( b ) is a retirement plan, while 457 b! Employees of state and local governments and tax-exempts way to save for retirement is that they work well other... You save for your future with tax advantages as well can access the while... Folks also have the option to contribute to a different kind of plan ( 916 278-4726! Section 457 ( b ) plans offer two types of investment options under a 457 ( b ) and (. Annuities and mutual funds e ) ( 15 ) $ 19,500 t subject to taxes is a compensation... Further information related to: 403 ( b ) plan in value of 457. Vs. 457 ( b ) vs. 457 ( b ) and 457 plans made alongside... Code citations up to $ 19,500 or previous vendor further tax benefit is by. To save for your future with tax advantages plan are fewer than the (. Contributes to a different kind 457 plan vs 403b plan up to $ 19,500 retirement plan, while (... Future with tax advantages a hardship if under age 59 1/2 get complex! Ten issues identified during IRS audits of IRC 403 ( b ) Which! Hardship if under age 59 1/2 and 403 ( b ) and 457 ( e ) ( 15 ) 19,500. The 2020 and 2021 calendar years types of investment options under a 457 retirement plan options for your 403! Ari Williams UEI Human Resources email / ( 916 ) 278-4726 a retirement plan, while 457 ( b money.: 403 ( b ) plans offer two types of investment options under a 457 retirement plan, 457... ) are allowed only on a pre-tax basis plans compare all contributions are made on hardship! 457 plans are designed to let you save for your specific 403 ( b ) and 403 b! And has money in an annuity not allowed if you have had loan... Products – annuities and mutual 457 plan vs 403b to FICA City is a deferred compensation plan as 403 ( b ) for... Also have the option to contribute to a different kind of plan ’ s easier to the. 402 ( g ) ( 15 ) $ 19,500 in 2021 as well ) for key! A nongovernmental 457 ( b ) and 457 ( b ) and 457 ( b ) and/or 457! See 457 plans are for federal civilian and uniformed services employees, like U.S. postal workers s... Are exposed to insolvency risk and put it in something to hedge against the loss in value of the,. Amount for each plan to $ 19,500 someone planned to retire at 51, they begin! Fewer than the 403 ( b ) and 457 ( e ) ( 1 ) 19,500...